Austerity v. Growth – Who is Correct?

In this must-read report from Brussels we see the clash of two big economic ideas, both in response to a time of global crisis.  The U.S., represented by Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew pushes spending, while Herman Van Rompuy, president of the European Council urges austerity.  Who is right?

Read this carefully.  Austerity Wars are underway, the U.S. vs Europe, and the stakes are very high.  Economic growth or fiscal frugality?

The question that Mr. Lew came to Europe to raise is how to strengthen the European economy — for the Continent’s sake, as well as for the global economy’s. The United States has an investment in Europe’s growth, American officials have said repeatedly, because of the deep financial and trade ties between the countries.

“We have an immense stake in Europe’s health and stability,” Mr. Lew said. “I was particularly interested in our European partners’ plans to strengthen sources of demand at a time of rising unemployment.”

The Obama administration has urged countries with stronger economies, like Germany, to slow their pace of fiscal retrenchment and ease off on demands for tougher cutbacks in hard-hit countries like Greece, Spain and Portugal. In the last few years, such advice has often fallen on deaf ears, given the political constraints in Europe and many officials’ belief in budget balance as a prerequisite to growth.

Mr. Van Rompuy mentioned the “vivid debate” over “fiscal policy and the pace of fiscal consolidation” in his remarks.

via In Effort to ‘Rebalance,’ Europe Appears Committed to Austerity Plan –

The new book by political economist Mark Blythe explores the history of the “myth”–or so he calls austerity.


From another vantage point, could another economic crisis of the past hold a useful lesson?

Tweak a few of the details and Mexico in the 1980s looks a lot like most Southern European countries today. In Mexico’s case, runaway government spending in the 1970s, fueled by high oil prices and greased by foreign debt, threatened to bankrupt the country after the Fed sharply raised interest rates to curb rampant inflation in the United States, increasing Mexico’s interest payments even as oil prices crashed to earth.

Similarly, money poured into Spain and Greece when investors persuaded themselves that the bonds of all members of the euro zone should be as safe as Germany’s, the region’s most creditworthy country. In Greece, this allowed a government spending binge. In Spain it ignited a housing bubble. Both countries were left with an unbearable burden when the world economy hit a wall, creditors took flight and the money stopped.

via Mexico’s 1980s Austerity Experience Holds Lesson for Europe –


2 thoughts on “Austerity v. Growth – Who is Correct?”

  1. Very interesting. I do think there is a need and benefit for Americans to be involved and educated about Europe’s financial goals because of how close ties are between the two countries concerning trade efforts. America’s push for spending should be evaluated with caution because, as we can tell, America is not in the best spot financially speaking either. I think the cure could be a balance of both strategies. I definitely think that spending can help in some circumstances, however saving should definitely be an aim as well.

    1. The pain that the United States will feel because of its deficits won’t truly be felt until governmental debt crowds out private investment when the economy returns to lower levels of unemployment, and the government stops its spending spree. The social contracts that have held fast during periods of long economic growth can’t continue, demographically our country’s shrinking birth rate has made entitlement programs unsustainable. There is going to be a lot of pain felt here when those contracts begin breaking down here in the states.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s