A New Call for Catalonia’s Independence – NYTimes.com

Regionalization continues as a prickly issue, particularly across Europe–sort of like the Trusteeship Council of the UN only in reverse, where established states break into parts.  Catalonia shares some common interests with Scotland (which has its own parliament), (Be sure to not confuse this with regionalism, seen in Benelux, the Nordic Council,  the European Coal and Steel Community, etc.)

But money isn’t the only cause of secessionist sentiment. We Catalans have long been attached to our distinct identity and never accepted the loss of national sovereignty after being defeated by the Spanish monarchy in 1714. For three centuries, Catalonia has striven to regain its independence. Most attempts to establish a state were put down by force. The “Catalan question” was a major catalyst of the Spanish Civil War in the 1930s, and Gen. Francisco Franco’s dictatorship harshly repressed Catalan culture.

At the core of Catalonia’s unique identity is the Catalan language, which is distinct from Spanish. Since the re-establishment of Spain’s democracy in 1977 and Catalonia’s autonomy in 1979, Catalan has been revived in the region’s schools. However, a recent ruling by Spain’s Constitutional Court threatens this policy. To most Catalans, our language is a red line. If the current system of autonomy can’t guarantee protection of it, independence is the only solution.

The independence movement is not driven by hatred of Spain. Catalan nationalism is civic and cultural, unlike the ethnic nationalism that has so often plagued Europe. Indeed, most of the two million Spaniards who migrated to Catalonia in the 1960s and ’70s are today fully integrated and many of them have embraced secessionist ideals

via A New Call for Catalonia’s Independence – NYTimes.com.

A following story from Sunday’s Week in Review section explores the issue further in the context of the economic forces confronting Europeans:

The crisis has also produced a loss of confidence in traditional leadership, with voters punishing incumbents and mainstream political parties. That has helped more atavistic nationalist parties, like the National Front in France and Golden Dawn in Greece. But in separatist regions, the same disaffection tends to favor parties advocating independence.

“The whole development of European integration has lowered the stakes for separation, because the entities that emerge know they don’t have to be fully autonomous and free-standing,” said Mark Leonard, the director of the European Council on Foreign Relations. “They know they’ll have access to a market of 500 million people and some of the protections of the E.U.”

Heather Grabbe, who worked for five years as a political adviser to the E.U.’s commissioner for enlargement, agreed: “If you’re a small country in the E.U., like Malta or Luxembourg, you’re likely to be overrepresented in Brussels compared to your size, so go for it.” Now the Brussels director for the Open Society Institute, Ms. Grabbe said the key variable for separatism is less a matter of money than of historical grievance and language.

via A European Union of More Nations? – NYTimes.com.


2 thoughts on “A New Call for Catalonia’s Independence – NYTimes.com”

  1. Though I appreciated many of the points made, this article makes it seem as though there will not be serious consequences for Catalonia if they suceed in gaining independance. It seems Catalonia will have to choose between preserving thier culture or continuing to be part of a competitive trade market via Spain. Catalonia’s asking for independance begs people to ask, is culture important? And if culture is important, does it have a chance to survive in a world of globalization, unions, etc. I do not agree that compared to the past, now is the most ideal time for Catalonia to break away from Spain. If they do so I believe they will experience a substantial economic crisis, however they will guarantee themselves a chance to preserve their culture and language for a bit longer, but is it worth the cost?

    This article presents a good argument: http://news.ph.msn.com/business/catalan-companies-fear-independence-drive

  2. Here’s an interesting addition to this article: “In December 2009, an informal referendum on Catalan independence took place, based on the question of whether Catalonia should become an independent state within the EU. Almost 95% of those who voted wanted Catalonia to leave Spain; however, Madrid dismissed the referendum and it had no legal impact, not least because only 30% of the 700,000 eligible voters turned up to vote.”

    Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-catalan-secession-movement-dangerously-close-to-derailing-spain-2012-9#ixzz28qYxvWU3

    As I read this article, I can’t help but wonder how I would react to a proposal made by another state to secede from the Union. I know that such a proposal is unlikely, but it helps me place myself in the shoes of the Spaniards at this time. I think it would be very difficult to have to cooperate with a region that has always seemed to want to split from the rest of the country, yet I feel for the Catalans who do fear that their culture is steadily being stamped out. I hold to my own traditions very closely — I feel like they do contribute significantly to my identity. Even if Catalonia wouldn’t really make much progress if it stood alone, maybe economics aren’t the most important thing in the hearts and minds of these people. Maybe the identity they perceive themselves as having in this world ultimately means more to them.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s